Comments on: Reader Case Study: Three Kids, Two Engineers and One Dog https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/ Financial independence and simple living Wed, 20 Sep 2023 18:41:59 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.3.6 By: Suzanne https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/#comment-494254 Tue, 25 Oct 2022 04:57:17 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=30468#comment-494254 In reply to Kara.

I went to college. My twin sister did not.
Today we are partners in a real estate business.
She is happy to point out that she earns the same as I do on our respective investments.

So maybe going to college didn’t make the difference. Hard work, good luck, the ability to understand the long term potential of real estate, and investing instead of spending our money was key to us both becoming financially successful.

With a side note: the couple in this case study earns a lot, and also pays a lot of taxes. Sometimes it’s better to earn less, spend less, and pay less in taxes.

]]>
By: Elle https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/#comment-483918 Wed, 17 Aug 2022 19:29:35 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=30468#comment-483918 In reply to Cara.

Yes! In state tuition & fees at the University of MA (a realistic in-state option for Matt’s kids) are about $17,000 a year, not including room and board. This also doesn’t include fees for the School of Engineering, the Business School or lab fees for science courses which could be about another $1000 a year. This would be about 24 hours a work of week at $15/hour (very reasonable here in Mass) to pay *just* tuition and fees without considering any housing, cost of living etc. I understand both Kate & Matt’s perspectives – it certainly isn’t a requirement that parents pay for their kids education, but if they are able to afford it without compromising their own future, as this couple is, it is such a great way to help them get a great start on their future.

]]>
By: elle https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/#comment-483914 Wed, 17 Aug 2022 19:11:32 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=30468#comment-483914 In reply to Alexa Kvande.

I didn’t qualify for work study aid so jobs on campus were limited as you mentioned. I was able to work as a swim instructor (wasn’t limited to work study students as the lesson fees paid for instructors and also they needed folks qualified to teach), I then became an RA which was also not limited to work study students – I didn’t get directly paid but did receive free housing, a free parking pass and a discount towards my meal plan, some schools pay directly. I also found an off-campus job that was within walking distance of my school – I ended up working there all through school as well as a summer in between jobs. For the most part though I worked VERY part time during the semester (less than 10 hours a week) and made up for it by working a LOT during the summer (at least one usually two jobs anywhere from 35 – 60 hours a week.)

]]>
By: Seana https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/#comment-367979 Wed, 12 May 2021 02:42:24 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=30468#comment-367979 In reply to Matt.

Yes, i use and like mint mobile. You need to be careful about your usage if you’re not on wifi because they throttle data – homestly between home and work I’m on wifi most of the time so it’s a non issue.

]]>
By: R quinn https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/#comment-362487 Mon, 05 Apr 2021 19:46:29 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=30468#comment-362487 Less than $9600 a year for property taxes on a $750,000 house near Boston. That’s quite a bargain. Why are they both paying for health, dental, ins? It may be less expensive for one to have family coverage, especially if there is employer based coverage.

]]>
By: monica https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/#comment-359708 Tue, 30 Mar 2021 20:27:11 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=30468#comment-359708 In reply to Matt.

Am pretty sure you have to pay regular interest on the 529 gain if you don’t use if for education. My older son got much more scholarship money than my younger, so I plan on using what was left in older son’s 529 for younger son’s education and then gifting the amount that was left in his 529 to my older son, but taking it from another account.

]]>
By: Holly https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/#comment-359098 Mon, 29 Mar 2021 22:00:24 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=30468#comment-359098 In reply to Matt.

As to being a bargain – yes, but now I’m paying the taxes! But I like our system better as progressive income tax seems like a much more equitable way to fund education than private debt. As to alum networks, it’s true that this isn’t really a thing in Canada, and while McGill would like to sell itself an Ivy of the North, there really is no such thing. Most Canadian universities are about equally good, unless you’re looking at a specific graduate or professional program.

]]>
By: Lena https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/#comment-358983 Mon, 29 Mar 2021 16:55:48 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=30468#comment-358983 In reply to Matt.

I recently bought a condo in a pricey Boston suburb off the T. Interest rates are very low right now. If you opt against paying off your mortgage (and based on above I would pay it off in your shoes), I’d look into refinancing.

]]>
By: monica https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/#comment-358514 Sun, 28 Mar 2021 23:19:21 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=30468#comment-358514 In reply to Claire.

As Matt noted in state schooling in MA is around 31K, but it is important to note that it is VERY COMPETITIVE. One of my kids who had a 3.9 GPA was not accepted to the main campus, so not only are MA state school expensive -m they are also competitive!

]]>
By: Allison https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/#comment-358298 Sun, 28 Mar 2021 15:21:10 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=30468#comment-358298 In reply to JessMarie.

I’m with JessMarie on this one. I have several friends and relatives who are multi-millionaires with liberal arts degrees. My best friend has an anthropology degree and has worked in finance all her life; she jokes that it gave her a good understanding of primate behaviour in brokers. She’s the VP of sales right now in a big multinational. My old boss, also a multi, has a film degree; my cousin, who until recently was CFO at a housing organisation in the UK, has a degree in old Norse (nope, I’m not making that up people!). And my oldest brother, by far the richest one of them all, has a year and a half of college under his belt, before deciding it wasn’t for him. And I’m very proud of my English degrees, but then I knew I wasn’t gong to be rich, ever; I just loved doing them for their own sake. And I’m not even remotely a trust fund baby either!

]]>
By: Emily https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/#comment-357792 Sat, 27 Mar 2021 20:00:01 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=30468#comment-357792 I just wanted to say — because I didn’t see it mentioned elsewhere — that one piece of the equation to give some thought to is what your expenses will really be like in retirement. A lot of the rule of thumb calculations (like 10X your salary) assume pretty high levels of income replacement are needed (sometimes like 75% or 80% of your income). But you already only spend 60% of what you earn, so you aren’t going to need to replace 80% of your income to retire! In fact, that 60% includes the savings to the 529, your mortgage, and lots of expenses for your kids that will go away when they move out. Retirement can come with some new expenses (especially around health insurance), but you might need less than you think and probably a lot less than the standard calculators assume.

]]>
By: Matt https://frugalwoods.com/2021/03/19/reader-case-study-three-kids-two-engineers-and-one-dog/#comment-357155 Fri, 26 Mar 2021 20:14:58 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=30468#comment-357155 In reply to Sarah.

Got it – thanks again!

]]>