Comments on: Reader Case Study: What Should We Do In The Last Decade Before Retirement? https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/ Financial independence and simple living Wed, 20 Sep 2023 12:18:30 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.3.6 By: Lesley https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/#comment-527679 Sun, 16 Jul 2023 12:39:50 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=36180#comment-527679 I am VERY late to this case study, but one part time job I immediately thought of that no one mentioned is to work in a garden center. It will allow you to be around the plants that you love, help others, maybe get a discount on items you need for your home garden, and bring in a small part time income. Best wishes in whatever you decide!

]]>
By: mary w https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/#comment-521648 Fri, 09 Jun 2023 18:12:37 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=36180#comment-521648 In reply to MaryP.

I think the “trick” is to find your niche. That could be affluent working people, the elderly, workday lunches or other niches I’m not thinking about.

]]>
By: Petra https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/#comment-519838 Sun, 28 May 2023 16:51:27 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=36180#comment-519838 I do feel like you guys are in a really good financial shape.

I would consider starting a cooking business and seeing whether that can bring in like $10k per year or so. No rush and no pressure, just see where you can go with this. I hope you’ll like the social aspect of it and the feeling of accomplishment, and the challenges. (And if not, you can quit it, too!).

]]>
By: Holly https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/#comment-519734 Sat, 27 May 2023 20:10:30 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=36180#comment-519734 In reply to Allison Carro.

Yes! And the comments are a super small font size as well. I always read them at 110% and it’s still not a great experience

]]>
By: Margaret https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/#comment-519680 Sat, 27 May 2023 13:06:47 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=36180#comment-519680 In reply to Bea.

I thought I would share my health insurance costs to add to your potential monthly expenses. My husband is on Medicare but I am not, but am eligible in 6 months. I work a part time job without health insurance benefits. I am self insured, currently paying $1800 per month for myself and my 19 year child. Since my husband still works, making good money, we are not eligible for an Obamacare subsidy. I think the income ceiling to get a subsidy is a bit over $50,000. You would need to carefully consider the cost of insuring your entire family, should your husband choose to retire early. While healthcare costs are deductible, they are still a big annual cost.

]]>
By: Jane https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/#comment-519515 Fri, 26 May 2023 11:54:41 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=36180#comment-519515 In reply to Jessica.

I do appreciate these detailed suggestions—-thx!

]]>
By: Carla https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/#comment-519431 Thu, 25 May 2023 18:55:25 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=36180#comment-519431 In reply to Jane.

If you have specific resources, you could post them on Teachers Pay Teachers. Just another option that may be lower lift than putting together and maintaining a website.

]]>
By: Melissa https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/#comment-519418 Thu, 25 May 2023 17:01:00 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=36180#comment-519418 Hi Jane,

Great job on saving – you are in a good position and have the flexibility to stay home or return to work as you’d like! I don’t have anything to add regarding financial advice, but I didn’t see any comments addressing the specifics of cooking for others/selling meals. If you do want to go down this road, I would recommend you research your state’s laws around food safety. Whenever you sell food, you are liable to restrictions/inspections by the state and local health department, and every state has different requirements.

I have some experience with this as I opened my own bakery business during the pandemic (my state has a cottage food law that allows me to sell shelf-stable food without my kitchen being inspected). I did lots of research and set up everything officially as a registered LLC for my own peace of mind and to protect my personal assets. I know some people who do things under the table and ignore these regulations. However, if the health department gets wind of it (which has happened before), your business can be shut down and you can face fines, etc. I just say this, because I honestly thought it would be pretty easy to sell food, and I realized it was a lot more involved than I thought. If you have any questions about owning a business, I would be happy to answer them 🙂

Cheers,
Melissa

]]>
By: Jessica https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/#comment-519398 Thu, 25 May 2023 13:42:16 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=36180#comment-519398 In reply to Sarah.

Basically a combination of what FW is recommending and what they’re already planning.
-1: Move the savings to a high yield savings account.
-2: Use the extra savings above emergency fund level to pay for the next 3 years of $10K/year deficit. This would leave them with a 3-4 month emergency fund.
-3: As they are doing that, start transitioning Jane’s 457b to a more risk-averse portfolio, planning to draw from this next.
-4: Use Jane’s 457b to pay for the remaining 6 years of $10K/year deficit. They would use most of the 457b this way.
-5: Joe retires!
Why I think this would work: Ignoring the checking, savings, and 457b, they currently have a bit under $1.2M, all in other retirement accounts. If we assume a 5% inflation-adjusted rate of return on the accounts, they would have over $1.8M by the time Joe retires, plus his social security at 67.

To be clear, I’m not saying they shouldn’t save more / work more / etc. when they feel fine doing so. But I don’t think they need to stress about it. They should have enough, and if they get particularly unlucky with any external factors (inflation, stock market, social security…), they seem like they would have plenty of options to deal with it.

Good point about the target date fund, I hadn’t thought about that!

]]>
By: Sarah https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/#comment-519275 Wed, 24 May 2023 15:59:55 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=36180#comment-519275 In reply to Jessica.

*They currently have a $10k/year deficit between their net take-home total and their expenses. Where would they draw the $ from?
*I agree that the simplicity of a target date fund is appealing, and they’re a great vehicle for younger investors. However, they get conservative quite quickly; for example, moving them more to a 60/40 split. It behooves Jane & Joe to align on a desired asset allocation and then construct a low-maintenance 3-fund portfolio.
*Fully agree re: health insurance, and I’m a broken record but I think FSAs are great. Especially with how many OTC items can be purchased through them now, it could easily reduce their household supplies line item.

]]>
By: Michele https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/#comment-519251 Wed, 24 May 2023 11:27:20 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=36180#comment-519251 In reply to Sarah.

I agree with all this advice, except contributing more to Joe’s 401k. I would only do up to the match, as you’re doing now, and put any remaining savings into Roth IRAs or the emergency fund. Actually, I’d vote for the emergency fund first b/c you may want to bump up your savings for new cars.

If it were me, I’d focus on your asset allocation ASAP. Being in 99% stocks is very risky! Eventually getting to 65/35 would be great. You might also check if consolidating any of the retirement accounts is possible for easier management.

Is your estate planning/beneficiary info all up to date? That’s important for you guys.

Thank you for sharing your lives in this case study! I found it very inspiring to read a story where the wife’s career was put first, and then you switched.

]]>
By: Jessica https://frugalwoods.com/2023/05/19/reader-case-study-what-should-we-do-in-the-last-decade-before-retirement/#comment-519188 Tue, 23 May 2023 23:30:09 +0000 https://frugalwoods.com/?p=36180#comment-519188 Using the same Rich Broke or Dead tool as Mrs FW, Jane & Joe would have a 100% chance of not running out of money if they changed absolutely nothing from their current plan (continued to spend 65000/yr, kept the same asset investment allocation, Joe’s salary remaining the same until he stops working at age 60, Joe takes social security at 67). This doesn’t account for any increases in spending (health care / insurance), but also ignores any reduction in housing expenses (from downsizing), so I think it’s fair to expect those factors should balance out. Based on that, I would say KUDOS for being in awesome shape to stick with your current plan. Jane does not need to return to work, even part time, and Jane & Joe don’t need to reduce their expenses.

Things to look into as you head into this next phase:
-You ask about asset allocation. An easy way to plan for this without being an expert is to use a target date fund, which automatically adjusts your amount of equities vs bonds based on nearness to retirement. Since you use Fidelity for most of your accounts, I looked up Fidelity’s target date funds. You would likely want to use the Fidelity Freedom Index 2030 Fund, FXIFX. It’s made up of index funds as Mrs. FW and many others always recommend, and the target retirement year is 2030 (closest option to 9 years from now). If you do this, careful to pick the Index fund (FXIFX, says Index in the name) rather than one of the other types of target date funds that are not index funds. FXIFX has an expense ratio slightly higher than your current ones, but still much lower than actively managed funds – I used this ratio when I filled out the Rich Broke or Dead calculator that I discussed above.
-If you want to consider other options such as Joe retiring earlier, I would highly suggest playing around with different options using the Rich Broke or Dead calculator.
-If Jane WANTS to work, by all means go ahead! 🙂 You have the freedom to choose based on your interests rather than based on salary. Hopefully this can assuage some of your concerns about the impact of your employment gap, which are otherwise quite valid.
-You ask about choosing your health insurance plan. What we generally know is that, if you do NOT expect to meet your deductible/out-of-pocket maximum, you should definitely choose the higher deductible (cheaper premium) plan. It is more likely to save you money overall. If you DO expect to meet your deductible/out-of-pocket maximum, it’s a wash and you can choose what you prefer. I personally choose the lower deductible (higher premium) plan for myself because I have expensive health care needs, and I feel emotionally better about just hitting my deductible/out-of-pocket max and then not feeling the impact of each individual bill. But that’s a personal choice and not necessarily optimal, because if I have a low healthcare cost year, I am losing out financially due to this choice.

]]>